Article
The Robusto Report

For the first test, we assemble a panel of new and experienced palates together at a venue (in this issue’s case, Club Macanudo, a veritable Versailles of cigars) and over a big dinner and drinks, have them smoke five cigars each.

April 2008 , Page 74

Page 3 of 6 » Next
« Back

continued

donpepin.300x250.jpg

Don Pepin Series JJ
Things didn’t start out too well for this cigar. “Flat spot. . . soft spot. . . beautiful cap, but. . . it’s really loose,” one taster opined as he took a “peppery” dry-draw on the medium-bodied stick, then lit up. General consensus was a “perfect,” “easy and powerful” draw, bringing with it “spicy, nuts and cocoa” notes that were nonetheless “unobtrusive.” The aroma of “sweet spice” settled around the puffer. “If a cigar was judged on flavor alone, this would be as great as it gets.” Fortunately, taste is often (nearly) everything.

Wrapper: Nicaragua
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaragua
$12.50/Stick
$240.00/Box of 20
Conclusion: OUTSTANDING


donaflor.300x250.jpg

Donaflor
This tightly wrapped and aesthetically pleasing Brazilian puro had a taste and aroma befitting its dark look. One taster found the dry draw was “woodsy,” while another found it “fruity” and yet another “spicy.” Once lit, though, all tasters found the cigar a cheek-sucking draw, although the “bold” aroma “If you’ve ever blown cigar smoke into a cognac and inhaled deeply. . . ” in one summary and rich, medium-to-strong taste of cedar, earth and berries somewhat made up for this.

Wrapper: Brazil
Binder: Brazil
Filler: Brazil
$5.50/Stick
$137.50/Box of 25
Conclusion: WORTHY


fuente.300x250.jpg

Fuente Fuente OpusX
Living up to its reputation, this “excellent, sturdy” stick produced no disappointments in the flavor, aroma, or draw department. The “nutty,” “peppery” flavor gave way to a “clean, light,” “woody” aftertaste, as ashtrays around the table filled with flaky ash. This “full-bodied” smoke was considered, in sum, “picture perfect.”

Wrapper: Dominican Republic
Binder: Dominican Republic
Filler: Dominican Republic
$11.75/Stick
$349.00/Box of 29
Conclusion: OUTSTANDING


griffins.300x250.jpg

Griffins Special XIII Edition
Despite its somewhat “unpolished” construction (“loose,” said one reviewer, while another thought the cap “poorly done”) and an unevenly colored wrapper with thick veins, we found this medium-bodied special edition “easy to light,” with a “buttery and inviting aroma” and a “woody flavor” with hints of tea and pepper. The ash was brittle and tended to flake. “Leaves an impression.”

Wrapper: Ecuador
Binder: Dominican Republic
Filler: Dominican Republic
$10.00/Stick
$100.00/Box of 10
Conclusion: WORTHY

Page 3 of 6 » Next
« Back

RELATED ARTICLES
April 2008
Table of Contents
NO COMMENTS YET
ADD YOUR COMMENT

Name Email
Subject
Comment
Scan this issue:

Next article » The Cigar Life Guide: Humidors

Previous article « Smoke Screen